How to appeal an MTD penalty

How to challenge a Making Tax Digital penalty point or charge, what counts as a reasonable excuse, and the time limit.

3 min read

Quick answer

Follow the instructions in the penalty letter to appeal. You can appeal penalty points, the £200 late submission penalty and late payment penalties. You usually need to appeal within 30 days of the date on the notice, and to show a reasonable excuse for missing the deadline.

What you can appeal

  • A penalty point for a missed deadline

  • A £200 late submission penalty

  • A late payment penalty

What counts as a reasonable excuse

Something unexpected or outside your control that stopped you meeting the deadline. Examples HMRC typically accepts include:

  • serious illness, or the death of a close relative, shortly before the deadline

  • a fire, flood or theft that stopped you getting to your records

  • failures in HMRC’s own systems or your software that you couldn’t reasonably avoid

Forgetting, relying on someone else, or not having the money usually aren’t accepted on their own.

How to appeal

  1. Read the penalty letter for the appeal route.

  2. Appeal within 30 days of the date on the notice.

  3. Explain what happened, when, and how it stopped you.

  4. Send the missing submission as soon as you can.

Related guides

Next guide

Do I pay tax quarterly under MTD? Payments on account explained

MTD Submission is an independent guide. We’re not HMRC, we’re not part of GOV.UK, and we don’t submit anything on your behalf. The information here is general, was last reviewed in September 2026, and isn’t tax or financial advice. For your own situation, check GOV.UK or speak to an accountant.

© 2026 Methodis Ltd. Registered in England and Wales, company number 16830157. Registered office: Suite A James Carter Road, Mildenhall, Bury St Edmunds, IP28 7DE.